By Nicholle Walton-Durban | Founder & Head of School, ESTEAM Academy
There is a fierce debate unfolding in Texas over Education Freedom Accounts (TEFA), and with a change in political leadership, questions about the program’s future have become even more urgent.
Depending on whom you ask, TEFA is either an important step toward educational freedom or a threat to public education. Supporters point to expanded opportunities for families. Critics raise concerns about funding, equity, accountability, and the long-term health of public schools. Even within the school-choice community, there are disagreements about whether accepting government funding might eventually compromise educational independence.
These are important questions. They deserve more than political talking points.
I’ve spent the past decade building learner-driven schools, working with families, and challenging many of the assumptions we’ve inherited about what education is supposed to look like. That experience has taught me something important: people can share the same goal and disagree profoundly about how to accomplish it.
I believe most of us want children to receive an excellent education. We want them prepared for life, equipped with meaningful skills, and capable of navigating an increasingly complicated world.
So why does the conversation become so divisive when someone suggests there might be more than one way to accomplish that?
And are we examining what is actually happening, or arguing about what we’re afraid might happen?
Let’s Start With the Money
One of the most repeated arguments against TEFA is that it takes money away from public schools.
It’s a serious concern. Public schools serve millions of Texas children, and their ability to operate effectively matters enormously. Funding affects teachers, facilities, special education services, transportation, and countless other resources.
But if we’re going to discuss the financial impact of TEFA, we need to understand how the program is funded.
Texas established TEFA through Senate Bill 2, with $1 billion in funding for the 2026–27 biennium. According to the Legislative Budget Board’s fiscal analysis, the program is funded through the state’s General Revenue Fund, with no direct expenditure from the Foundation School Fund in fiscal years 2026 and 2027.
During the same legislative session, Texas also approved approximately $8.5 billion in additional public education funding for the 2026–27 biennium, including funding associated with House Bill 2.
Public-school funding and TEFA funding were both priorities of that legislative session.
That doesn’t mean TEFA has no financial implications for public schools. District funding is affected by enrollment and attendance, and when students leave, revenue can change while many operating expenses remain. Future TEFA appropriations also compete with other possible uses of state revenue.
But there is a meaningful difference between saying TEFA directly takes money from the public-school funding account and saying expanded educational choice may affect school district finances over time.
Those are different claims, and they deserve different conversations.
We also need to consider what we’re measuring. Educational funding is often discussed in terms of what institutions receive. Yet the reason we invest public dollars in education is to serve children.
That doesn’t eliminate our responsibility to maintain strong public schools. It does invite us to ask whether supporting public education and supporting alternative educational pathways must be competing priorities.
If our goal is to educate children well, how do we determine whether our investment is working? By the financial stability of the institutions receiving the money, by the outcomes experienced by learners, or by some thoughtful combination of both?
Is Educational Choice Really Only for Wealthy Families?
Another common criticism is that programs like TEFA primarily benefit families who already have the financial resources to choose private education.
It’s a legitimate concern. Even with financial assistance, tuition differences, transportation, admissions requirements, and school availability can create barriers.
But there’s another side to the equation.
Families with significant financial resources have always had educational choices. They can pay private-school tuition, relocate to a preferred school district, hire tutors, or build customized educational experiences.
Families without those resources often have far fewer options.
For the 2026–27 school year, the standard TEFA award for a student attending a participating private school is $10,474. Eligible students with qualifying individualized education programs may receive additional funding, up to $30,000. Homeschooling families may receive $2,000.
When applications exceed available funding, the program uses eligibility and prioritization rules that give particular consideration to students with disabilities and families at lower income levels.
These provisions don’t guarantee equal access. A family may still struggle to find an appropriate school, cover remaining tuition, or arrange transportation.
But they do create opportunities that some families might not otherwise have.
The important question isn’t simply how many families receive awards. It’s whether the program is expanding meaningful access, particularly for families who previously had few realistic alternatives.
That requires examining who applies, who receives funding, who ultimately enrolls, and who remains unable to participate.
If educational choice has historically been easiest for families with financial means, does restricting financial assistance make educational access more equitable? Or does it leave those existing advantages largely intact?
Perhaps the more productive conversation is about how to make educational options genuinely accessible.
What About Accountability?
Another frequently raised argument is that private schools receiving public funding aren’t held to the same accountability standards as public schools.
And that’s true. They operate under different models, with different expectations and different measures of success.
But different doesn’t mean unaccountable.
Participating TEFA private schools must meet accreditation requirements, have operated for at least two school years, and administer annual nationally norm-referenced assessments to participating students in grades 3–12. The program also establishes restrictions on how funds may be spent.
These are accountability measures. They simply aren’t identical to those governing public schools.
But there’s another form of accountability that often gets overlooked: the families themselves.
At ESTEAM Academy, we’ve spent a decade building a learner-driven model that looks very different from a conventional classroom. Academics are essential, but families also come to us because they want their children developing real-world skills: independence, critical thinking, communication, problem-solving, and the ability to take ownership of their decisions.
Those aren’t secondary benefits. They’re central to what we’re building.
And our families hold us accountable for delivering on that promise.
Like other independent schools, we operate in an environment where families choose whether to enroll and whether to stay. We listen closely to our community, refine our programs based on what we’re learning, and have the flexibility to pivot when something isn’t working. We don’t have to wait for a statewide policy change to reconsider how we’re serving our learners.
Our continued success depends on families finding value in what we provide. If we consistently fail to deliver, families can leave, enrollment can decline, and our ability to operate is directly affected.
That doesn’t mean every family’s experience is identical or that enrollment alone measures academic achievement. It means the people closest to the educational experience have a meaningful voice in determining whether we’re delivering what we promised.
And that raises a question worth considering.
If families are intentionally choosing a different educational model, why would we assume that model must be evaluated by exactly the same measures as the one they chose to leave?
Perhaps the distinction isn’t between schools that are accountable and schools that aren’t.
It’s between different models of education, with different measures of success, answering to the people they are designed to serve.
Does Accepting Educational Funding Mean Surrendering Educational Freedom?
There’s another concern in the TEFA debate that deserves particular attention, and it comes from a community that has spent decades advocating for educational freedom: Texas homeschool families.
Their concern isn’t necessarily that families shouldn’t have educational choices. It’s that accepting government funding may eventually invite government control into educational environments that families fought hard to keep independent.
And there’s history behind that concern.
In the landmark Leeper v. Arlington Independent School District case, Texas families fought to establish the legal standing of homeschooling. The resulting court decisions affirmed that qualifying homeschools could operate under the private-school exemption from compulsory attendance.
Today, the Texas Education Agency does not regulate, register, monitor, or accredit ordinary homeschool programs.
That independence matters. It was hard-earned, and it deserves to be protected.
So when homeschool advocates question whether government funding could become a pathway to government oversight, I think we ought to listen.
But we should also examine what the law actually says.
First, participation in TEFA is voluntary. Families are not required to accept funding, and private schools are not required to participate. Choosing to educate a child independently does not, by itself, trigger TEFA’s participation requirements.
Second, participating families and schools accept specific conditions. Private schools must meet accreditation and assessment requirements, while homeschool families receiving TEFA funds must follow the program’s rules governing eligible expenses and financial oversight.
Those distinctions matter. Accountability for the use of public money is not automatically the same thing as government control over educational content.
And Texas lawmakers anticipated this concern.
Section 29.368 of the Texas Education Code specifically protects the autonomy of participating families and educational providers, including their freedom to determine educational methods and curriculum. It also restricts program-related government actions that would interfere with certain institutional and religious practices.
That doesn’t mean concerns about future government overreach disappear. Laws can change. Regulations can evolve. Any program involving public funding deserves ongoing scrutiny of whether its existing protections are being respected.
But there’s a difference between recognizing that possibility and concluding that government control is an inevitable consequence of accepting TEFA.
If we believe educational independence is worth protecting, why wouldn’t we insist on preserving the boundaries that protect it?
Could we maintain accountability for how public funds are spent without giving government authority over educational philosophy or curriculum? Could we protect the independence of families and schools that decline funding while allowing others to participate voluntarily?
And could we agree that those protections should remain in place regardless of which political party holds office?
Perhaps the challenge isn’t choosing between educational freedom and financial accessibility.
It’s preserving both.
But Won’t School Choice Hurt Public Education?
I understand this concern, particularly from educators who have dedicated their careers to serving children in public schools.
I also believe it’s possible to care deeply about public education while recognizing that public schools are not the ideal environment for every learner.
Some children thrive in traditional classrooms. Others thrive in project-based environments, Montessori schools, career-focused programs, homeschooling communities, microschools, or other educational settings.
The reasons vary. Sometimes it’s a matter of learning style or pace. Sometimes a child needs a different social environment, greater flexibility, specialized support, or an educational philosophy that better aligns with the family’s priorities.
And sometimes a family simply wants something different.
That doesn’t make their neighborhood school a failure.
It means children and families are not interchangeable.
One of the things I’ve learned through building schools is that even an educational model I believe in deeply isn’t necessarily the right fit for everyone.
I don’t want every family to choose ESTEAM.
I want families to understand what we offer, determine whether it aligns with their values and their child’s needs, and make an informed decision.
And I want them to have meaningful alternatives when it doesn’t.
We should also be willing to examine how educational choice affects the schools families leave behind. Strong public schools remain essential, and their students deserve continued investment and support.
But preserving a strong public-school system and allowing families access to other educational environments don’t have to be mutually exclusive goals.
What if we stopped treating a family’s decision to choose a different school as a rejection of public education and started treating it as information worth understanding?
What are those families looking for? What needs weren’t being met? What are they finding elsewhere?
And what might every educational model learn from those answers?
Have We Actually Asked the Families?
This is the part of the conversation I find most troubling.
We have plenty of predictions about what TEFA will do.
We hear what it might cost, whom it might benefit, how it might affect public schools, and what problems it might create.
Some of those concerns may prove valid. Others may not.
But now that families are actually participating, shouldn’t we be paying attention to their experiences?
Have we asked parents what educational options they had before receiving TEFA funding?
Have we asked why they wanted something different, what barriers they faced, and whether the funding was enough to make their preferred option possible?
Have we asked what has changed for their children?
And have we asked the schools serving these learners what they’re seeing? Are families arriving with different expectations? Are schools able to meet their needs? What challenges are emerging that policymakers might not have anticipated?
Perhaps most importantly, have we asked the learners themselves?
We should also hear from families who didn’t receive funding, couldn’t find a participating school, or discovered that an award still wasn’t enough to make their preferred option affordable.
Their experiences matter just as much.
And the same curiosity should extend to public-school communities. What are districts experiencing? How are enrollment patterns changing? Which concerns are proving valid, and which might be addressed through better policy?
TEFA is a new program. It’s too early to make sweeping claims about its long-term academic, financial, or social outcomes. Early experiences can help us understand what’s working and what needs improvement, but they aren’t substitutes for rigorous evaluation over time.
The same standard should apply to supporters and critics.
There’s a difference between identifying a potential risk and demonstrating that harm has occurred. Just as there’s a difference between celebrating an opportunity and proving that it has delivered lasting results.
Both deserve evidence.
Before we decide what needs to be dismantled, defended, or redesigned, perhaps we ought to listen to the people directly affected.
Are we genuinely curious about what is happening?
Or have we already decided what we believe will happen?
What Are We Actually Trying to Protect?
Public education is one of the most important investments we make as a society. An educated population benefits all of us, regardless of whether we have children attending school.
But a commitment to education doesn’t necessarily require a commitment to only one method of delivering it.
We should want excellent public schools, responsible use of public funds, meaningful educational options for families, and policies that respond to evidence rather than political allegiance.
Those goals are not inherently incompatible.
For ten years, I’ve watched what can happen when we question inherited assumptions about education. I’ve also learned that creating something different doesn’t exempt us from criticism, accountability, or the responsibility to keep improving.
In fact, it makes those things even more important.
TEFA is not a perfect program. There are legitimate questions about its implementation, accessibility, and long-term impact. We ought to keep asking them, just as we should continue examining the effectiveness of every educational system.
And if the evidence shows that something isn’t working, we ought to have the courage to change it.
Perhaps the greatest risk in this debate isn’t that we’ll disagree about the best way to educate children.
It’s that we’ll become so committed to defending our preferred systems that we’ll stop being curious about what children actually need.
Which brings me back to the question that started this conversation:
If we genuinely believe every child deserves a quality education, why wouldn’t we be willing to examine more than one way to deliver it?
And perhaps an even more challenging one:
Are we willing to let the evidence change our minds?
Let’s Keep the Conversation Going
These are my observations, experiences, and questions after a decade of building learner-driven schools and working alongside families who have chosen a different educational path. They reflect what I’ve seen, what I’ve learned, and what I continue to question.
I don’t expect everyone to agree with my conclusions. In fact, I hope you’ll challenge them.
I’ve included the sources below because I believe these conversations deserve more than headlines, assumptions, or someone else’s interpretation of the facts—including mine.
Read the legislation. Explore the data. Talk to families, educators, and schools. Ask questions that might challenge what you already believe, and remain curious about what you discover.
And if you see something differently, I’d genuinely love to hear why.
I’m looking forward to continuing the conversation.
Curious About a Different Approach to Education?
At ESTEAM Academy, we’ve spent the past decade building a learner-driven community where young people practice agency, ownership, accountability, and self-leadership every day.
We believe education can look different, and we’re committed to helping families understand what that difference means.
If you’re exploring educational alternatives for your child, including options that may be supported through Texas Education Freedom Accounts, we invite you to learn more about our community.
Explore if ESTEAM Academy is right for your family
For official TEFA program information, eligibility, and future application opportunities, visit Texas Education Freedom Accounts.
Sources & Further Reading
The following primary sources informed the factual and legislative portions of this article. I encourage readers to examine them directly, explore the context, and draw their own conclusions.
- Texas Legislative Budget Board — Senate Bill 2 Fiscal Note (April 24, 2025). Initial TEFA funding, fiscal impact, and the distinction between the General Revenue Fund and Foundation School Fund.https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/89R/fiscalnotes/html/SB00002F.htm
- Texas Legislative Budget Board — Fiscal Size-Up, 2026–27 Biennium. State education appropriations, including public-school funding increases and the TEFA appropriation.https://www.lbb.texas.gov/Documents/Publications/Fiscal_SizeUp/9046_Fiscal_Size-up_26-27_Biennium.pdf
- Texas Education Agency — 2025 Annual Report: House Bill 2. Public education funding increases and how the new funding is allocated.https://tea.texas.gov/about-tea/newsroom/annual-reports/annual-report-2025-house-bill-2-historic-school-finance-bill.pdf
- Texas Education Freedom Accounts — Official Program Information. Award amounts, eligibility, prioritization, and participation requirements for families.https://educationfreedom.texas.gov/families/
- Texas Education Freedom Accounts — Participating School Requirements. Accreditation, operating history, and student assessment requirements.https://educationfreedom.texas.gov/schools/
- Texas Education Code §29.368 — Program Participant, Provider, and Vendor Autonomy. Statutory protections concerning educational methods, curriculum, and institutional independence.https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/docs/ED/htm/ED.29.htm
- Texas Education Agency — Home Schooling. Texas homeschool law, the Leeper decision, and the state’s role in homeschool regulation.https://tea.texas.gov/families-and-students/finding-school-your-child/home-schooling
Legislative and program information reviewed November 14, 2026. TEFA award amounts and eligibility provisions referenced in this article apply to the 2026–27 school year.

